Peaches: Cold Hardy
Peach varieties listed here, particularly those rated for zone 5a, have demonstrated the ability to produce a decent crop after experiencing temperatures between -10F and -20F. However, reports are very few in number for every variety except Contender, which consistently excels over those it has been compared to. Contender is a must have for anyone attempting to grow peaches in zone 5, and it is best paired with a relatively hardy rootstock. Those with "frost resistant" flower buds aren't necessarily hardy when it comes to winter lows, but based on the information that is currently available, they appear to tolerate, or avoid, late frosts better than most.
Baby Crawford
Discovered in Escalon, California.
Zone
• 5a
• 800 chill hours
• 800 chill hours
Flowers
• showy
Blooms
💮
• ◦ frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• mid-late
• 3 to 3.5 weeks after Redhaven
• 3 to 3.5 weeks after Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone
• light fuzz
• light fuzz
Afflictions
• At least somewhat susceptible to bacterial spot?
Carolina Gold
Biscoe x NC-C5S-067 (Encore x Calanda San Miguel 2383). Originated in North Carolina, PP17780 (2004).
Zone
• 5
• 1050 chill hours
• 1050 chill hours
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ at least somewhat frost resistant?
Ripens
🍑
• late
• 4 to 4.5 weeks after Redhaven
• 4 to 4.5 weeks after Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone, light fuzz
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Challenger
Redhaven x (Reliance x Biscoe). Originated in North Carolina, PP12375 (1999).
Zone
• 5
• 950 chill hours
• 950 chill hours
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ at least somewhat frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• early-mid
• 1 week after Redhaven
• 1 week after Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
China Pearl
Contender x PI 134401. Developed in North Carolina, PP11914 (1998).
Zone
• 5
• 900-1100 chill hours
• 900-1100 chill hours
Flowers
• showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• late
• 4.5 to 5 weeks after Redhaven
• 4.5 to 5 weeks after Redhaven
Color
• white flesh
Fruit
• freestone
• low acid
• low acid
Afflictions
• Somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Contender
Winblo x NC64 (Summercrest x Redhaven)? Introduced in North Carolina (1987-1989).
Zone
• 5a
• 1050 chill hours
• 1050 chill hours
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• mid-late
• 3 weeks after Redhaven
• 3 weeks after Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Growth
• upright growth
Fruit
• freestone
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Whether it comes to late frosts or winter lows, Contender is clearly the most consistent producer after an unfavorably cold weather event. This ultimately makes it a very popular variety, and while the quality the peach is fairly good, there are better ones out there for the few in North America who do not benefit from this advantage.
Early Redhaven
bud mutation of Redhaven
Zone
• 5
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• ◦ somewhat frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• early
• 2 weeks before Redhaven
• 2 weeks before Redhaven
Fruit
• semi-freestone
Encore
Consists of Autumnglo, Krasvynos, and White Hale in its parentage. Developed in New Jersey, Introduced in 1980.
Zone
• 5
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ at least somewhat frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• late
• 4.5 to 5 weeks after Redhaven
• 4.5 to 5 weeks after Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Encore peaches struggle to develop enough sugar often enough to be a concern.
Ernie's Choice
unknown parentage
Zone
• 5 ◦ 850 chill hours
Flowers
• showy
Blooms
💮
• ◦ at least somewhat frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• mid
• 2.5 weeks after Redhaven
• short harvest season
• 2.5 weeks after Redhaven
• short harvest season
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone
• firm
• high acid
• firm
• high acid
Afflictions
• Somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Poor weather can cause Ernie's Choice to become too tart, otherwise it is reputed to have a very good and relatively strong flavor for those who prefer a good amount of acid with their fruit.
Frost
Zone
• 5
• 700 chill hours
• 700 chill hours
Ripens
🍑
• mid
• roughly 1.5 weeks after Redhaven
• roughly 1.5 weeks after Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• semi-freestone
Afflictions
• Somewhat resistant to leaf curl.
Garnet Beauty
Bud mutation of Redhaven. Introduced in Ruthven, Ontario (1958).
Zone
• 5
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ somewhat frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• early
• 1.5 to 2 weeks before Redhaven
• 1.5 to 2 weeks before Redhaven
Fruit
• semi-freestone
• light fuzz
• light fuzz
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Harrow Diamond
Redskin x Harbinger. Developed in Ontario.
Zone
• 5a ◦ 850+ chill hours
Flowers
• showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• very early
• 3 weeks before Redhaven
• 3 weeks before Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Growth
• medium vigor
Fruit
• semi-freestone
Afflictions
• Resistant to bacterial spot. At least somewhat resistant to brown rot and canker.
Harrow Diamond may not produce the best tasting peaches, but it has a decent reputation for a variety that ripens this early. Additionally, it is generally more tolerant of the cold, more disease resistant, and less vigorous than the alternatives that ripen around this time.
Indian Free
Alias
• Blood Free
Zone
• 5
Flowers
• showy
Blooms
💮
• very late
Ripens
🍑
• very late
• roughly 8 weeks after Redhaven
• roughly 8 weeks after Redhaven
Color
• red flesh, tan skin
Fruit
• freestone
• high acid
• high acid
Afflictions
• Somewhat resistant to leaf curl.
Susceptible to bacterial spot.
Susceptible to bacterial spot.
Indian Free develops a unique flavor, but the grow season may not be long enough for it to ripen in most zone 5 areas, which is unfortunate, because it has supposedly performed quite well after experiencing zone 5b temperatures for a few people (at least on one occasion).
Intrepid
Redhaven x (Reliance x Biscoe). Developed in North Carolina, PP12357 (1999).
Zone
• 5
• 1000+ chill hours
• 1000+ chill hours
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ at least somewhat frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• mid
• roughly 2 weeks after Redhaven
• roughly 2 weeks after Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Madison
Ideal x Redhaven. Developed in Virginia (1963).
Zone
• 5
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ at least somewhat frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• mid-late (late)
• 3.5 to 4 weeks after Redhaven
• 3.5 to 4 weeks after Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone, light fuzz
Afflictions
• Somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
PF 24C
Developed in Michigan. PP15659
Zone
• 5
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ somewhat frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• mid-late
• 3.5 weeks after Redhaven
• 3.5 weeks after Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Growth
• medium vigor
Fruit
• freestone
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Polly
Originated in Iowa
Zone
• 5a
• 1000 chill hours
• 1000 chill hours
Flowers
• showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ at least somewhat frost resistant?
Ripens
🍑
• mid
• 1 or 2 weeks after Redhaven
• 1 or 2 weeks after Redhaven
Color
• white flesh
Fruit
• freestone
Ranger
Zone
• 5
• 900 chill hours
• 900 chill hours
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ at least somewhat frost resistant?
Ripens
🍑
• possibly 1 week after Redhaven, but information is sparse and contradicting.
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Ranger is supposedly one of the more cold hardy, frost resistant peach varieties, but I can hardly find any information about it.
Redhaven
Halehaven x Kalhaven. Introduced in Michigan (1940).
Zone
• 5a
• 800 chill hours
• 800 chill hours
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• ◦ at least somewhat frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• early-mid
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• semi-freestone
• semi-firm
• semi-firm
Afflictions
• Somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Redhaven generally ripens early to mid August in the northern half of the United States.
Redhaven is compatible with the American plum rootstock (Prunus americana), as are a few other varieties mentioned in the "Read More" section.
Reliance
? x Meredith. Developed in New Hampshire (1964).
Zone
• 5a
• 1000 chill hours
• 1000 chill hours
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• early-mid
• 0 to 0.5 weeks after Redhaven
• drops when ripe
• 0 to 0.5 weeks after Redhaven
• drops when ripe
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone
Storage
• short shelf-life
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Reliance may not have as good of a reputation as most other varieties, but oftentimes, it manages to develop a good peach flavor.
Risingstar
Zone
• 5a
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• early (early-mid)
• 1 to 2 weeks before Redhaven
• 1 to 2 weeks before Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• semi-freestone
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to bacterial spot and canker.
There is some indication that Risingstar may prove to be one of the hardiest peach varieties available, but more experimentation is needed.
This is currently the only image I have of a non-showy peach flower on this site.
Salish Summer
Discovered in Washington
Alias
• Q18
Zone
• 5
• 700-800 chill hours
• 700-800 chill hours
Ripens
🍑
• early-mid
• roughly 1 week after Redhaven
• roughly 1 week after Redhaven
Color
• white flesh
Fruit
• semi-freestone
Afflictions
• Somewhat resistant to leaf curl.
Saturn
NJ 602903 x Pallas. Developed in New Jersey, PP5123 (1982).
Zone
• 5
• 400 chill hours
• 400 chill hours
Flowers
• showy
Blooms
💮
• early ◦ at least somewhat frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• early-mid
• 0.5 weeks before Redhaven
• 0.5 weeks before Redhaven
Color
• white flesh
Fruit
• donut-type
• freestone
• light fuzz
• high sugar
• low acid
• freestone
• light fuzz
• high sugar
• low acid
Afflictions
• Resistant to bacterial spot.
Saturn may lack flavor for some and tear at the stem when picked, but its high sugar content compensates for many. It also appears to be hardier and (at least slightly) more flavorful than Galaxy, which is another donut peach that ripens about a week later, but Saturn is smaller in size by a fairly significant amount.
Siberian C
unknown parentage
Zone
• 5a
Flowers
• showy
Blooms
💮
• late
Ripens
🍑
• late
Color
• white flesh with some green.
Fruit
• small-size
Storage
• short shelf-life
Afflictions
• Resistant to bacterial spot. Somewhat resistant to leaf curl.
If there is anything that can compete against Contender when it comes to tolerance of the cold, it would probably be Siberian C, based on how well it performed against other (more unknown) varieties when tested in the past. The problem is, information from home-growers about the hardiness of the tree is very difficult to come by. Furthermore, I believe Siberian C generally refers to a strain rather than a specific selection, so some of these traits may vary a bit.
Assuming the trees I have sampled from are Siberian C (as claimed), which I believe they are, they can have a good and rather unique flavor with a decent amount of acid for a white peach, but they are fairly small and have a short shelf-life. Additionally, they were quite bitter during the first or second year they produced, but after that, there has been little to no bitterness. Siberian C ripens in late September in my Dfb climate.
Surecrop
Zone
• 5a ◦ 1000 chill hours
Flowers
• non-showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• early
• ~2 weeks before Redhaven
• ~2 weeks before Redhaven
Fruit
• semi-freestone
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
Surecrop is one of the hardier peach varieties, but its quality suffers often enough to be a concern.
Veteran
Early Elberta x Vaughn. Developed in Canada (1928).
Zone
• 5a
• 900 chill hours
• 900 chill hours
Flowers
• showy
Blooms
💮
• late ◦ frost resistant
Ripens
🍑
• mid-late
• 3 (maybe 4) weeks after Redhaven
• 3 (maybe 4) weeks after Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone or semi-freestone, heavy fuzz
Peaches: Notable Mentions
Nanaimo
Discovered in British Columbia
Ripens
🍑
• around Redhaven, according to one claim.
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone
Afflictions
• At least somewhat resistant to leaf curl.
In-spite of (supposedly) being one of the most resistant to peach leaf curl, Nanaimo is still at least somewhat susceptible in the climate experienced near the west coast. In fact, it sounds like it has no actual resistance in much of the area due to exceedingly wet weather during spring, but a few people have supposedly had some success.
I currently do not see much of a pattern that points to one curl resistant variety being superior to most others, but 'Oregon Curl Free' might have the edge. Conversely, 'Mary Jane' apparently has less resistance than what was previously implied.
Red Baron
PP4195
Zone
• 6 ◦ 250-300 chill hours
Blooms
💮
• early
Ripens
🍑
• mid?
• at least 1 or 2 weeks after Redhaven, I believe.
• at least 1 or 2 weeks after Redhaven, I believe.
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• freestone
• heavy fuzz
• heavy fuzz
Afflictions
• Somewhat resistant to bacterial spot.
The Red Baron peach produces ornamental double red blossoms.
Rich May
Developed in Modesto, California (1991).
Zone
• 6 ◦ 800-900 chill hours
Blooms
💮
• late
Ripens
🍑
• very early ◦ 5 weeks before Redhaven
Color
• yellow flesh
Fruit
• clingstone
• firm
• firm
Afflictions
• Somewhat susceptible to bacterial spot.
Rich May is one of the earliest ripening peach varieties. While I am not sure how it compares to some of the best tasting varieties, it is known for being very good for a variety that ripens this early. It is probably not appropriate for zone 5, though.